GandGLLP_logo2GandGLLP_logo2GandGLLP_logo2GandGLLP_logo2
  • Home
  • About
  • Expert Areas
    • Banking & Financial Services
    • Commercial Litigation & Dispute Resolution
    • Corporate & Commercial
    • Corporate Restructuring & Insolvency
    • Employment
    • Private Client
    • Family Law
    • Real Estate
  • People
  • Careers
  • News & Insights
  • Contact
✕

Limiting the Burden of Extensive Discovery

July 2018

A July 2018 judgment of Judge Hogan in the Court of Appeal may further restrain the ability of parties to seek extensive discovery in litigation matters.

A July 2018 judgment of Judge Hogan in the Court of Appeal may further restrain the ability of parties to seek extensive discovery in litigation matters.

In the case of Tobin -v- The Minister for Defence, Judge Hogan ruled that the courts ought to refuse orders for extensive discovery in circumstances where the applicant has not exhausted all other avenues and shown them to be insufficient. The Judge went as far as to say there is currently a “crisis” in the discovery process, with disproportionate “burdens, costs and delays” being imposed on litigants and the wider legal system.

The discovery order initially granted in the High Court against the Minister would have required locating and cataloging vast quantities of hard copy documents dating back some 28 years, which Judge Hogan agreed would have created a very considerable burden on the Department. He also suggested that the size of such larger organisations and the resources at their disposal ought not to be taken into account when granting extensive discovery applications.

The result of this case is likely to be welcomed by legal professionals who are familiar with the arduous nature of the discovery process. However, the judgment also increases the duty on litigants to take a “cooperative approach” and to seek discovery by other means such as through consent, interrogatories, and notices to admit facts.

For further information contact Helena Walsh

CONTACT

+353 1 872 9299
Lawyer@GoreGrimes.ie

ADDRESS

Gore & Grimes Solicitors LLP
Three Haddington Buildings
Percy Place
Dublin 4
D04 T253
Ireland

Gore & Grimes Solicitors LLP is authorised by the Legal Services Regulatory Authority to operate as a Limited Liability Partnership pursuant to section 125 of the Legal Services Regulation Act 2015.

© Gore and Grimes 2023 Privacy NoticeSite by Begley Hutton