In a recent High Court case before Justice Twomey, the Court was posed with the question of whether or not a settlement agreement negotiated outside of court can remove the obligation on a Defendant to reimburse the Department of Social Welfare. While this question had been answered in the negative by the Court on a previous occasion, the current case looked to answer whether the situation might be different if one of the Defendants is a State Body
Justice Twomey’s recent High Court ruling provides clarity on the issue of whether the Plaintiff and Defendant in a personal injury action can decide amongst themselves that the Defendant does not have to reimburse the Department of Social Welfare (the “Department”). Typically, when a settlement agreement is reached, the parties decide between themselves how responsible each party should be for the injury. For example, the Defendant might agree to liability of 60% with the remainder of the blame falling to the Plaintiff. The Defendant must then reimburse the Department in proportion to their liability.
In the present case, the Department had paid out €42,000 to the Plaintiff and the parties were requesting that the Court incorporate a term from their settlement agreement into the Court Order stating that the Defendant did not have to reimburse the Department irrespective of their liability. This issue had previously been dealt with by Justice Twomey in Szwarc v. Hanford Commercial t/a Maldron Hotel Wexford [2021] IEHC 474 (“Szwarc”) and here the Court refused to find that terms included in private settlements could be included in an Order of the Court. The Court stated that including such a term in a Court Order would result in the taxpayer paying for the Defendant’s financial liability to the State. The parties argued that the present case differed from Szwarc as the Second-Named Defendant, The Health Service Executive (“HSE”) is a State Body. They argued that unlike in Szwarc where the Defendant was an insurance company, if the HSE did not reimburse the Department, this would not create a loss for the taxpayer but that it would merely transfer the loss from one State Body to another.
Despite the submissions by the parties, the Court refused to allow the term in the settlement agreement to form part of the Court Order. One of the main reasons for doing so was because the term had not been decided by an independent observer (the Court) and the parties to the settlement agreement had a vested financial interest in the term being included. The Court was also heavily persuaded by the fact that including the term would have a negative financial impact on a third party who did not have an opportunity to be heard during the course of the settlement negotiations. Judge Twomey also held that the HSE should not be treated differently to insurance companies. The Court did not find that the distinction was relevant and noted that although the HSE and The Department are State Bodies, they nonetheless have their own separate budgets and financial interests and to assume that they are one and the same is inaccurate.
Justice Twomey’s decision makes it clear that Defendants to an action must always reimburse the Department in proportion to their liability unless otherwise decided by a court. This decision has not made any significant changes to the law, nonetheless, it strongly reiterates the position that Defendants who wish to settle an action, must take into account their liability to the Department when negotiating a settlement figure.
Cookie | Duration | Description |
---|---|---|
cookielawinfo-checkbox-advertisement | 1 year | Set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin, this cookie is used to record the user consent for the cookies in the "Advertisement" category . |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional | 11 months | The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. |
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". |
CookieLawInfoConsent | 1 year | CookieYes sets this cookie to store the user consent. |
viewed_cookie_policy | 11 months | The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data. |
Cookie | Duration | Description |
---|---|---|
_ga | 1 year 1 month 4 days | The _ga cookie, installed by Google Analytics, calculates visitor, session and campaign data and also keeps track of site usage for the site's analytics report. The cookie stores information anonymously and assigns a randomly generated number to recognize unique visitors. |
_gat_gtag_UA_* | 1 minute | Google Analytics sets this cookie to store a unique user ID. |
_gid | 1 day | Installed by Google Analytics, _gid cookie stores information on how visitors use a website, while also creating an analytics report of the website's performance. Some of the data that are collected include the number of visitors, their source, and the pages they visit anonymously. |
CONSENT | 2 years | YouTube sets this cookie via embedded youtube-videos and registers anonymous statistical data. |
Cookie | Duration | Description |
---|---|---|
VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE | 5 months 27 days | A cookie set by YouTube to measure bandwidth that determines whether the user gets the new or old player interface. |
YSC | session | YSC cookie is set by Youtube and is used to track the views of embedded videos on Youtube pages. |
yt-remote-connected-devices | never | YouTube sets this cookie to store the video preferences of the user using embedded YouTube video. |
yt-remote-device-id | never | YouTube sets this cookie to store the video preferences of the user using embedded YouTube video. |